PolitiClone
Political Pundits? India

Modi’s Falsification of History cannot Fool the Diaspora

Why did Modi chose the distant Indian diaspora to unload the most absurd claims regarding the achievements of the NDA Government of the 1999-2004 period? Is it because his countrymen wouldn’t buy such falsehood and Modi wanted a faraway audience to gulp down his pill of falsity?
But how does he expect the NRIs who have been living in America since ages to believe that in the years between 2000 to 2004, when the Americans were themselves sunk in the worst crisis of their own after 9/11/2001, the Indian economy would be booming without their FDI? A quick look at the actual data in respect of the Indian economy for the period 1999 to 2013 may make further discussion on the issue quite redundant:

Average Growth Rate - NDA and UPA

Year (NDA Rule) 1999-20002000-2001 2001-20022002-2003 2003-2004Average
India's Real GDP Growth Rates7.59 4.35.52 3.998.06 5.892
Agriculture growth (%) 2.67 -0.016.01 -6.69.05 2.224
Industry growth (%) 5.966.03 2.617.21 7.325.826
Services growth (%)11.19 5.37 6.886.97 8.067.694




Year (UPA Rule)2004-2005 2005-2006 2006-20072007-2008 2008-2009Average
India's Real GDP Growth Rates 6.979.48 9.579.32 6.728.412
Agriculture growth (%)0.18 5.14 4.165.8 0.093.074
Industry growth (%) 9.819.72 12.179.67 4.449.162
Services growth (%)8.13 10.9110.06 10.279.98 9.87




Year (UPA Rule)2009-2010 2010-2011 2011-20122012-2013 Average
India's Real GDP Growth Rates 8.599.32 6.214.96 7.27
Agriculture growth (%)0.81 7.94 3.651.79 3.5475
Industry growth (%) 9.169.16 3.493.12 6.2325
Services growth (%)10.5 9.758.2 6.59
8.76
Average Growth Rate of GDP, Agriculture, Industries and Service sectors of one term of NDA and two terms of UPA (Data courtesy Planning Commission Records)
Growth Rate Graph NDA, UPA1, UPA2
Growth Rate Graph NDA, UPA1, UPA2
It can be seen that the Vajpayee led NDA had inherited an economy which had a GDP growth rate of 7.9% which nose-dived to 4.3% to 5.52% to 3.99% in three years. It did recover to 8.09% and the average for the entire five year was 5.89%. The next UPA Government hit the highest GDP Growth rate 9.57% in 2006-07 and ended with an average of 8.14%, much higher than the NDA average. Even in their second term, UPA hit the high of 9.32%in 2010-11 and till 2013 has got an average GDP growth rate of 7.27%. In all the three sectors, namely, Agriculture, Industry and Service, the growth rates under the UPA rule are consistently higher.
Our purpose is not to applaud the high rates of growth from 2007 to 2011 under the UPA rule but to point out the utter falsity of Modi’s claims. However the figures would indicate that the economic growth achievements during UPA rule were far superior than what was achieved by NDA, contrary to Modi’s claims. We also know that the reason for the aforesaid growth rate has little to do with the indigenous development of Agriculture or Industry but had a lot to do with the FDI and FIIs entering the Indian market plus the expansion of the service sector. The Indian economy is so intimately locked with the Global economy that if any person claims that if BJP is brought to power the Indian economy will turn around by itself, people will laugh at him. Modi is making such a fool out of himself.
He stoops further while addressing the NRIs and claims that Atal Behari tested the first nuclear bomb when it was Indira Gandhi who had actually tested the first nuclear bomb; but neither Indira Gandhi nor Atal Behari Vajpayee brought any glory to our country by doing so. Moreover, what is the message that Modi wants to send to the Americans – that if brought to power, BJP’s Government will test a nuclear bomb for the third time that would send China scurrying?

My Blog List


PolitiClone Comments

Recent Posts

PolitiClone

Blog Archive

Visitors