The UP Congress chief, Ms Rita Bahuguna Joshi’s arrest and the subsequent drama have diverted attention from the fact that a woman Dalit chief minister has conveniently forgotten the Supreme Court directive to keep the identity of rape victims under wraps, says RASHEEDA BHAGAT.
The UP Congress chief, Ms Rita Bahuguna Joshi… Caught in a political quagmire. There was never a doubt about how high the stakes are for appropriating political space in Uttar Pradesh. But that race has just got hotter and uglier after the arrest of the UP Congress chief, Ms Rita Bahuguna Joshi, for her unseemly remarks against the UP Chief Minister, Ms Mayawati. The latter seems to be operating on a one-point agenda when it comes to political rivals — nothing short of packing them off to the
kali kothdi. And so Ms Joshi was jailed for her controversial and unsavoury remarks against Ms Mayawati in the context of the paltry compensation for Dalit women who had been raped.
In a rally in Moradabad, the Congress UP chief had scoffed at the paltry compensation of Rs 20,000 handed out to raped Dalit women. So far so good, but then, obviously carried away, she stepped into a political minefield and made a highly objectionable statement about Ms Mayawati.
Ms Joshi played straight into Ms Mayawati’s hands by her obnoxious comments; charges under Section 153 A (delivering inflammatory speeches) and Section 109 (using abusive language) of the IPC, as well as the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act 1989, were slapped against her for making derogatory remarks against a Dalit woman, and she was remanded to judicial custody.
Worse followed, her house was attacked and torched and despite its close vicinity to the high security zone of the State Secretariat, any security or police apparatus was mysteriously absent when hooligans shouted slogans against her and burnt the house. Conveniently enough, shortly before the attack, the police rounded up her personal staff such as driver, cook, etc and took them away to the police thana. Apparently, they were told that the police was acting thus to safeguard their own security!
High handed As expected, all hell broke loose and cutting across party lines most politicians condemned the language used by Ms Joshi and Ms Mayawati’s high-handed act in imprisoning her. Ms Mayawati’s
bete noir, Samajwadi party chief, Mr Mulayam Singh, and the BJP MP, Ms Maneka Gandhi, whose son Varun, was imprisoned and the National Security Act slapped against him for his inflammatory speech against Muslims during his election campaign in Pilibhit, sought her dismissal. Other politicians, including those from the Left parties, have condemned Ms Joshi’s arrest, particularly the attack on her house, allegedly at the behest of Bahujan Samaj Party supporters. One of BSP’s MLAs, Mr Babloo Tiwari has been named in an FIR registered with the police; the charge is that he had led the mob that vandalised Ms Joshi’s house in Lucknow.
The Congress, of course, described the entire episode as one more example of “jungle raj” in UP and Mr Akhilesh Yadav, Mr Mulayam’s son, said the continuance of Ms Mayawati at the helm in UP was untenable and her government should be dismissed. “Law and order has gone for a toss in the State. In Uttar Pradesh, it is not the police but BSP leaders who decide what sections are to be imposed on a criminal,” he said.
But the reaction that everybody was waiting for was that of the Congress President, Ms Sonia Gandhi, and Ms Mayawati was the first to point it out, wondering why Ms Sonia had remained a silent spectator. But soon enough Ms Gandhi did respond, expressed regret at the comments made by Ms Joshi but also condemned what had happened after that as extremely “high handed”.
Battle for UP But at the bottom of this acrimony and the violence displayed in vandalising Ms Joshi’s Lucknow residence, is the battle for UP, once again by bandying caste politics. After her spectacular victory in the last UP Assembly elections, Ms Mayawati’s hopes of heading a Third Party coalition government in Delhi after the Lok Sabha elections had gained ground. The squabbling between the SP and Congress over seat-sharing had only whetted her appetite. But her calculations that the BSP’s huge Assembly victory would naturally be transferred to a great showing in the Lok Sabha polls were dashed to the ground by the Congress General Secretary, Rahul Gandhi’s decision to go it alone in UP yielding surprisingly good results for the Congress.
In the run-up to the Lok Sabha polls, the Amethi MP put his nose to the ground and dexterously ploughed his way through the quagmire of UP’s caste politics. Surpassing even the Congress’ own expectations, it won a whopping 21 seats in UP, and what must have really hurt the BSP supremo, who was expecting to win about 45 seats in UP, was that the Congress won an extra seat, compared to its 20! The SP’s share came tumbling down from its 36 in 2004 to only 23 seats in 2009.
The Congress’s sterling performance devastated both the UP chieftains — Mr Mulayam and Ms Mayawati; the last time the Congress had won more than 10 seats in UP was in 1989 when it got 15 seats; in 2004, it was able to manage a miserable nine seats.
To the astute politician in Ms Mayawati, this was a clear signal that after yielding a chunk of its political influence in the Hindi heartland to the regional parties and the BJP, the Congress is heading for a spirited fight to regain the State which has consistently returned Nehru-Gandhi family members to the Lok Sabha.
Obviously, she has realised that her ‘
sarva samaj’ mantra that worked magic in the 2007 Assembly elections did not help in the Lok Sabha polls, and other parties such as the Congress had whittled away its Dalit vote-bank. Just as the severe action against Varun Gandhi was meant to show Muslims that she could be their saviour if only given a chance, Ms Joshi’s arrest and threatening noises on how she will be “punished” even if she gets bail, etc, is a clear signal from Ms Mayawati to the Dalits that she is their
sole saviour.
Ms Joshi’s arrest and the drama that ensued have unfortunately diverted attention from the fact that a woman chief minister, and a Dalit to boot, seems to have conveniently forgotten the directive that has come from none less than the Supreme Court that it is obligatory on the part of the government, NGOs, as well as the media, to keep the identity of rape victims under wraps.
The central debate should have been on the lining up of rape victims to give government compensation, which could have been quietly reached to their homes. But, then, unpublicised largesse gives little opportunity to any political party to let not only the victims, but their entire community, know who their real saviour is. Thus are vote bank politics born, nurtured and fiercely guarded.
Rahul Gandhi has sent the right message when he recently asked Youth Congress workers to go to villages and work for the poor, irrespective of their caste and community. But if our politicians had half a chance they would fight tooth and nail to get the ‘poor’ notified as a different caste altogether!